Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Selling Over the Holidays in Tampa Bay? What 9 Years of Listing Data Show

Selling Over the Holidays in Tampa Bay? What 9 Years of Listing Data Show

Every November, sellers ask me the same question: should I list now, or wait until after the holidays? The common instinct is to wait. Nobody wants showings during Thanksgiving, and January feels like a fresh start.

My take: I'd rather list now than wait for January, because a lot of sellers wait, and that's exactly what makes January more crowded. But you shouldn't take my word for it. Here's what nine years of Tampa Bay listing data actually show, including the trade-offs.

What the data covers

The numbers below come from Realtor.com's monthly housing inventory data, published through the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), for the Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater metro area: Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco and Hernando counties. The newest month available is October 2026. These are listing counts (homes coming on the market, sitting on the market, or going pending), not closed sales, and they cover all listing types in the metro, so your neighborhood and price point can run differently.

December is consistently the slowest month for new listings

From 2017 through 2025, the Tampa metro averaged about 5,700 to 6,600 new listings a month for most of the year. December averaged about 4,600. It was the lowest month for new listings in eight of those nine years. The one exception was 2020, when April dipped lower during the pandemic shutdown.

Then January hits. In seven of the last nine winters, new listings jumped 29% to 52% from December to January. The two pandemic winters (2020-21 and 2021-22) were the only times the jump was single digits. Last winter was the biggest jump in the series: 3,986 new listings in December 2025, then 6,072 in January 2026, up 52%.

Two bar charts of Tampa metro new listings from Realtor.com. Top: average new listings by month 2017-2025, with December lowest at about 4,600 versus 5,700 to 6,600 in other months. Bottom: January new listings rose 40%, 35%, 40%, 7%, 6%, 29%, 36%, 41% and 52% over the prior December for winters 2017-18 through 2025-26.

In plain English: if you list in late November or December, fewer new homes are coming on the market to compete with yours. If you wait for January, you're launching at the same time as a wave of other sellers who had the same idea.

The trade-off: buyers slow down too

Listing in December isn't a free win, and I'm not going to pretend it is. Buyer activity also slows over the holidays:

  • Fewer homes go under contract. From 2017 to 2025, the metro averaged about 6,600 pending listings in December, compared with about 9,000 in March and April.
  • Homes sit longer. Median days on market averaged about 61 days in December and 62 in January, versus about 48 in March and April.

So the question isn't "is December busy?" It isn't. The question is whether less competition for the buyers who are out there is worth more to you than a bigger crowd of buyers in spring. Buyers shopping in December tend to be serious: job relocations, lease endings, people who want to close by a certain date. They're also looking at a smaller selection.

Where the Tampa Bay market stands right now (October 2026)

The latest monthly numbers show supply getting thinner heading into the holidays, not thicker:

  • New listings: 5,008 in October 2026, down about 5% from 5,292 in October 2025, and the lowest October total in Realtor.com's data for this metro, which goes back to 2016.
  • Active listings: 18,190, down about 2% from 18,623 a year earlier. That's still well above where inventory sat before 2020, so buyers do have choices.
  • Pending listings: 4,823, also the lowest October in the series. Buyers are being careful.
  • Median days on market: 77, compared with 79 a year ago.
  • Median list price: $385,000, down from $409,000 in October 2025. That's asking prices, not sale prices.
  • Price reductions: 7,208 listings had a price cut in October, roughly 4 in 10 active listings.

Put together: buyers are deliberate and price-sensitive, and a lot of listings are chasing the market down with price cuts. I covered that in more detail in why price cuts are outpacing new listings in Tampa Bay. A holiday listing that's priced right from day one stands out. One that starts high and cuts in January ends up competing with every new January listing.

If you list over the holidays, do it right

  • Price it for today's market, not last spring's. With roughly 4 in 10 listings taking a price cut, overpricing is the fastest way to waste the quiet window. Start with a current home valuation and real recent comps.
  • Don't skip the little things. I don't think sellers waste money getting a home ready. Skipping the small stuff is what makes a listing sit and go stale. Curb appeal matters, and the mailbox is underrated. A leaning, beat-up mailbox is the first thing a buyer sees.
  • Keep holiday decor light. A wreath and some greenery photograph well. A yard full of inflatables doesn't. Buyers need to picture the house as theirs.
  • Be flexible on showings. Holiday-season buyers are often on a deadline. Block out the days you truly can't show, and make the rest easy.
  • Know your timeline. A home listed in mid-December that goes under contract in early January can still close in February, ahead of the spring crowd's closings.

When waiting makes sense

Waiting until January or later can be the right call if the house genuinely isn't ready, if you need repairs finished first (a roof or plumbing issue that will show up on a four-point inspection, for example), or if your own next move isn't lined up. A rushed, unprepared listing in December is worse than a well-prepared one in February. If you're weighing it, my seller resources walk through the prep.

Sources

Featured photo: "Cottage with Christmas decorations in Pensacola, Florida, 2019" by Carol M. Highsmith, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Market figures are listing data, not closed sales, and are general information, not a guarantee of how any one home will sell.

Work With Dean

Partner with Dean Diakonis for a strategic, personalized real estate experience built on clear communication, market knowledge, and your goals.

Follow Me on Instagram